Toy Store is a business that operates a consumer-facing retail environment with foot traffic, product liability, and inventory theft exposure. The most important coverages for Toy Store operations are Workers' Compensation, Commercial Property — protecting your business from the lawsuits, property losses, and employee injuries most common in this industry. Workers' compensation is legally required in most states for any employer with employees. Get rate data from top-rated carriers and your Certificate of Insurance in minutes. Rate data from top-rated carriers nationwide. Rates from $60/month.
Starting rate shown is a national estimate for a standard policy. Actual premiums vary by state, revenue, employee count, claims history, and coverage limits.
By clicking, you agree to My Digital Kube's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, and authorize My Digital Kube and its affiliated carrier partners to contact you using the information you provide during the quoting process. Consent is not a condition of obtaining a quote.
Instant COI
Same-day certificate of insurance
Avg. ~10 min
Quote to COI — per ERGO Next
| State | Est. Monthly Rate | Cost vs National | Compare |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | $53–$220/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Arizona | $63–$263/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Arkansas | $51–$213/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| California | $87–$363/mo | High Cost | View cities → |
| Colorado | $69–$288/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Connecticut | $78–$325/mo | High Cost | View cities → |
| Delaware | $63–$263/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Georgia | $63–$263/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Florida | $71–$295/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Idaho | $57–$238/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Illinois | $72–$300/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Indiana | $55–$230/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Iowa | $53–$220/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Kansas | $54–$225/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Kentucky | $53–$220/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Louisiana | $66–$275/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Maine | $60–$250/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Maryland | $75–$313/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Massachusetts | $81–$338/mo | High Cost | View cities → |
| Michigan | $75–$313/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Minnesota | $66–$275/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Mississippi | $49–$205/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Missouri | $57–$238/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Montana | $57–$238/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Nebraska | $54–$225/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Nevada | $69–$288/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| New Hampshire | $69–$288/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| New Jersey | $84–$350/mo | High Cost | View cities → |
| New Mexico | $54–$225/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| New York | $87–$363/mo | High Cost | View cities → |
| North Carolina | $63–$263/mo | Average | View cities → |
| North Dakota | $55–$230/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Ohio | $59–$245/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Oklahoma | $54–$225/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Oregon | $69–$288/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Pennsylvania | $66–$275/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Rhode Island | $72–$300/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| South Carolina | $59–$245/mo | Average | View cities → |
| South Dakota | $53–$220/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Tennessee | $57–$238/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Texas | $66–$275/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Utah | $63–$263/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Vermont | $63–$263/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Virginia | $69–$288/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| Washington | $75–$313/mo | Above Average | View cities → |
| West Virginia | $49–$205/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
| Wisconsin | $61–$255/mo | Average | View cities → |
| Wyoming | $53–$220/mo | Below Average | View cities → |
Required in most states for any employer with employees. Covers medical expenses, lost wages, and employer liability for on-the-job injuries.
Covers your business building, equipment, inventory, and fixtures against fire, theft, vandalism, and other covered perils.
Examples of real-world claim types for Toy Store businesses. Amounts shown reflect industry settlement ranges. Not all scenarios are covered under Business Owner's Policy (BOP) — employee injuries require Workers' Compensation; alcohol-related incidents require Liquor Liability.
Appetite ratings reflect how actively each carrier writes toy store policies. AM Best ratings reflect financial strength as of 2026.Source: AM Best, carrier filings, NCCI data.
| Carrier | AM Best | Appetite | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| NEXT Insurance (ERGO)Available Here | A (Excellent) | Excellent | Varies by class |
| The Hartford | A+ (Superior) | Good | Varies |
| Travelers | A++ (Superior) | Good | Varies |
| Nationwide | A+ (Superior) | Good | Varies |
| Liberty Mutual | A (Excellent) | Moderate | Varies |
By clicking, you agree to My Digital Kube's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, and authorize My Digital Kube and its affiliated carrier partners to contact you using the information you provide during the quoting process. Consent is not a condition of obtaining a quote.
Rate ranges are estimates based on industry averages for businesses with under $500K revenue, no prior claims, and standard policy limits. Your rate may vary.
Adjust the sliders to get a personalized estimate. Takes 30 seconds.
Estimated Business Owner's Policy (BOP) Cost
for Toy Store in Illinois
per month
~$864–$3,600 per year
Instant COI. No agent needed.
By clicking, you agree to My Digital Kube's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, and authorize My Digital Kube and its affiliated carrier partners to contact you using the information you provide during the quoting process. Consent is not a condition of obtaining a quote.
* Estimates are based on national industry benchmarks adjusted for state cost index, business size, revenue, and claims history. Not a guaranteed quote. Actual premiums vary by carrier, underwriting factors, and coverage limits selected. Consult a licensed insurance professional for binding coverage.
National average: $60–$250/month ($720–$3,000/year). Rates vary significantly by state, city, revenue, employees, and claims history. High-cost metros like New York City and San Francisco run 50–80% above the national average.
Business Owner's Policy (BOP) bundles general liability and commercial property into one cost-saving package. For Toy Store businesses specifically, common covered scenarios include: customer or third-party claims arising from your operations, damage caused to client property, and incidents occurring at your business location. Note: employee injuries are covered by Workers' Compensation (not GL), and liquor liability requires a separate Liquor Liability policy if you serve alcohol.
Toy Store businesses face a range of exposures that may require multiple types of coverage — not all of which fall under Business Owner's Policy (BOP). Common industry risks include: Customer slip and fall in store; Product liability from sold merchandise; Employee injury during stocking; Shoplifting and employee theft; Property damage from fire or vandalism; Credit card data breach. A licensed broker can help match each risk to the right policy type.
Most commercial leases, client contracts, and licensing boards require proof of business owner's policy (bop) before you can operate. Even where not legally required, it's effectively mandatory to win commercial work.
Top carriers for Retail businesses: The Hartford, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Coterie, Thimble, CNA, Employers, and Markel. Availability and pricing vary by state and business profile.
Yes — most Toy Store policies can be quoted and bound same-day through ERGO Next's platform. A Certificate of Insurance is available instantly after binding.
Most contracts require $1M/$2M GL limits. Higher-risk operations or those working with enterprise clients often need $2M/$4M. Work with a licensed broker to match limits to your contracts.
Yes — business insurance premiums are generally tax deductible as an ordinary and necessary business expense. Consult your tax advisor for specifics on your situation.
Most toy store businesses need more than BP coverage. Here are the other policies that typically apply:
Other retail businesses that need similar BP coverage:
Rate estimates are national averages adjusted by state cost index (2026). Content reviewed by My Digital Kube editorial team, licensed commercial insurance professionals.
About this content: My Digital Kube is an independent insurance comparison platform operated by a licensed insurance agency. Commercial insurance rate estimates on this page are derived from publicly available carrier rate filings, NCCI data, and industry benchmarks — not live carrier quotes. Actual premiums vary by payroll, revenue, claims history, state, and individual underwriting. Coverage information was reviewed by licensed property and casualty professionals. Last reviewed: October 2026. Editorial Policy →